The first step in assuring compliant payroll is to audit the payroll processes currently in place across your labour supply chain. This should include:
- Your own internal processes as the end-hirer.
- Every agency on your Preferred Supplier List (PSL).
- Any umbrella companies supplying labour to your business.
The audit should assess the effectiveness of each party’s compliance controls, particularly in relation to PAYE and/or CIS obligations.
Confirm that deductions shown on payslips are actually remitted to HMRC (evidence from Business Tax Account/bank) and that RTI/CIS returns reconcile.
Further Considerations
As an end-hirer, it’s vital to understand HMRC’s Supervision, Direction or Control (SDC) test. Where a worker is subject to SDC by any person, the agency legislation (ITEPA 2003 s44, as amended) generally requires the intermediary (usually the agency) to operate PAYE. For umbrella employees, SDC mainly affects eligibility for tax-free travel & subsistence expenses.
You should also be familiar with the 2014 Onshore Employment Intermediaries rules (which strengthened s44 “agency” legislation). They were introduced to tackle false self-employment—where employment is misrepresented as self-employment to avoid Income Tax and NICs.